They all produced essentially the same results in density, texture, and color, but the shape of the cupcakes varied. The toast setting works by emitting even heat from the top and bottom of the oven, similar to the way a 2 or 4-slice slot toaster emits heat on two sides of the bread simultaneously. For this setting, we placed the wire racks on the middle level of the toaster ovens. For the five finalists that allowed us to choose a level, we set the toaster ovens to level two. A formidable size, the Cuisinart also boasts a high 1800 watts in order to preheat quickly and cook effectively. The cooking results of the Cuisinart were nearly identical to the Breville.
I was initially skeptical about Cuisinart’s TOA-65 Air Fryer Toaster Oven. Its roughly 17 x 22 x 16 inch size seemed too large to merit space on my counter, and I couldn’t imagine myself luging it out of a cabinet to toast a bagel or air fry onion rings. However, as I tested each of its seven features, my judge-y disposition faded; every setting nailed it — from toast to French fries.
It’s digital, so there are 10 programmed settings of time and temperature for a variety of foods, all of which can be adjusted depending on your recipe or packaging instructions. For example, the Pizza function is set at 350°F for 30 minutes, and we adjusted it to 450°F. The Pizza function uses convection, and the pizza was done in 13 minutes.
We tested three different toast shades, from lightest to darkest, and all were evenly colored with no burnt or under-toasted edges. Combining all of these user-friendly features, the Breville toaster oven was clearly designed with the customer in mind. The average consumer could painlessly operate the Breville using his or her intuition alone. For those who prefer to read the instructions, the easy-to-read instruction book is comprehensive and includes several bonus recipes. I followed the recipe in the instruction manual for classic roast chicken. I was skeptical about the 45 minute cook time, as my chicken packaging advised almost two hours in a normal oven for a 4lb chicken.
The tray is an essential feature because it makes cleaning your toaster oven much easier. When it came to evenly toasting bread, the majority of our finalists were disappointing, including our new finalist, the KitchenAid. Most cuisinart toaster costco of the toaster ovens produced shading that graduated from top to bottom with the edges of the bread either under- or over-toasted. In our prior testing, only the Oster and the Waring evenly toasted the bread on both sides.
The Oster 6-Slice Counter Top Oven is the largest toaster oven that we tested, with the ability to fit six slices of bread, a 12-inch pizza, and a whole chicken. It provides six different pre-set cooking functions cuisinart toa60 along with its convection mode. While its convection fan didn’t yield cupcakes as light and moist as our top two choices, the Oster was one of the two toaster ovens to produce evenly shaded toast.